god I am awful.
Dec. 9th, 2015 09:48 pmTonight we attended the school Christmas play. This is often pretty fun and entertaining. From tiny four/five year olds shuffling around and looking confused as members of the nativity to the older kids doing dance routines and reciting stuff about Christmas and then all the children singing a lovely Christmas carol or two. I really enjoy going to this every year.
It started off well with my daughter's class (reception, year one and two) doing a story of The Stickman meets the nativity. Miss Biscuit who has had a nasty cough (but pushed through because when you put that damn child on the stage she performs like Judy Garland) was the clock narrator, and then did this greek song/dance with the girls in her class and she had a bit of a solo. Again she is not shy on stage. She doesn't have the Ethel Merman voice that her friend E. has but you don't miss her.
Then came Senor Onion's class. (Year 3 and 4) and they did a version of Babushka and the Three Kings. He was a king, said his lines clearly and obviously had the best head of hair on stage. Seriously. He has very pretty hair.
My nieces were in that as well and E. who is very shy did a great job at singing, and G. who is less shy was a fantastic dancing star. I love a good folk-tale.
Then came the oldest class. (years 5 and 6) I noticed as they came in they all seemed to have... ethnic costumes. I side-eyed Mr. Jenner but thought, "okay. Let's see what happens. It could be good. A parent who had attended the preschool class/morning performance said it was funny. I now view that parent as having bad taste in comedy even if she is a lovely person with lovely children and I like her very much otherwise.
The basic premise is a bunch of people being stuck in an airport on Christmas Eve. The one genuinely funny bit was one of the kids doing the voice announcements. She captured that sort of sing-songy calm in the face of chaos announcements you get at the airport and on planes. She was funny. After that it was not so funny.
There were many pairs of kids and I am going to pause and state the obvious; here in this bit of rural England, the population is pretty damn white. We have one child in the school who is from Thailand but pretty much everyone else? WHITE. From a socio-economic perspective it is pretty varied. There are some kids who come from quite a bit of money and some who do not. Anyhow... they were all various... ethnic stereotypes. And the kids put on assorted accents to go with it. And I get that they wanted to do a thing about Christmas around the world and you can do that without veering into that territory. I wondered if it was just me who was thrown by this British sense of obliviousness to privilege and how they perceive the world around them. I asked Mr. Jenner and he said he cringed through the whole thing. I was grateful that the kids who had afros on (they were being people from Jamaica.) didn't black up. (nor did the red-headed kid who was being someone from India. Some accents though...)
And I get there is still this strangely twee view of the French and Italians. But the rest was uncomfortable. Really. A couple of kids being "Mexicans" (and that one really bothered me because yo, that is friends and family and there is soooo much to Mexican culture -especially when it comes to Christmas.) and the hokey versions of Scottish and Irish people. It was like being stuck experiencing "It's a Small World After All" circa 1962. Only with added bad bad jokes. Poor kids. Stuck with terrible writing. (the Americans of course were cowboys.) And then Santa comes and all is well and we have learned something about a couple of cultures along the way. (mainly that in Germany the Christ child brings presents and cowboys in America sing a carol about cowboys at Christmas.)
I've been talking about it with some other friends because I really wondered if I was waaaaaaaaaaaay off base or what. I figured that if Mr. Jenner (who is probably the least reactionary person I know, and who can view many things through a fairly objective perspective) sees this as being awful, it is awful. I mean would they put this play on in other parts of England? I kept thinking, "would this play in London?"
I think that after the play is over I want to have a tiny chat with the headmistress. I want to ask where that particular play came from and say how much I liked the other two and how the kids obviously worked very hard but maybe... it is good to consider (especially in this day and age) the nuances of the material chosen. And if she ever wants the kids to actually learn a bit more about certain cultures why not have more people come in to educate the kids. and I am happy to volunteer with some of these things. I want to think about this a bit because I want her to be open to listen to another perspective "OMG this is freaking uncool." and offer solutions in a polite way. "Hey these aren't far off funny stereotypes. These are real people with complex cultures and experiences and this doesn't help the kids much. Especially if you want them go be well educated and thoughtful members of society." (probably wouldn't help if I yelled, "These are my friends and family dammit. This isn't funny. Do you ever read a fucking book?")
Anyhow...
My children are talented and good looking but I knew that.
It started off well with my daughter's class (reception, year one and two) doing a story of The Stickman meets the nativity. Miss Biscuit who has had a nasty cough (but pushed through because when you put that damn child on the stage she performs like Judy Garland) was the clock narrator, and then did this greek song/dance with the girls in her class and she had a bit of a solo. Again she is not shy on stage. She doesn't have the Ethel Merman voice that her friend E. has but you don't miss her.
Then came Senor Onion's class. (Year 3 and 4) and they did a version of Babushka and the Three Kings. He was a king, said his lines clearly and obviously had the best head of hair on stage. Seriously. He has very pretty hair.
My nieces were in that as well and E. who is very shy did a great job at singing, and G. who is less shy was a fantastic dancing star. I love a good folk-tale.
Then came the oldest class. (years 5 and 6) I noticed as they came in they all seemed to have... ethnic costumes. I side-eyed Mr. Jenner but thought, "okay. Let's see what happens. It could be good. A parent who had attended the preschool class/morning performance said it was funny. I now view that parent as having bad taste in comedy even if she is a lovely person with lovely children and I like her very much otherwise.
The basic premise is a bunch of people being stuck in an airport on Christmas Eve. The one genuinely funny bit was one of the kids doing the voice announcements. She captured that sort of sing-songy calm in the face of chaos announcements you get at the airport and on planes. She was funny. After that it was not so funny.
There were many pairs of kids and I am going to pause and state the obvious; here in this bit of rural England, the population is pretty damn white. We have one child in the school who is from Thailand but pretty much everyone else? WHITE. From a socio-economic perspective it is pretty varied. There are some kids who come from quite a bit of money and some who do not. Anyhow... they were all various... ethnic stereotypes. And the kids put on assorted accents to go with it. And I get that they wanted to do a thing about Christmas around the world and you can do that without veering into that territory. I wondered if it was just me who was thrown by this British sense of obliviousness to privilege and how they perceive the world around them. I asked Mr. Jenner and he said he cringed through the whole thing. I was grateful that the kids who had afros on (they were being people from Jamaica.) didn't black up. (nor did the red-headed kid who was being someone from India. Some accents though...)
And I get there is still this strangely twee view of the French and Italians. But the rest was uncomfortable. Really. A couple of kids being "Mexicans" (and that one really bothered me because yo, that is friends and family and there is soooo much to Mexican culture -especially when it comes to Christmas.) and the hokey versions of Scottish and Irish people. It was like being stuck experiencing "It's a Small World After All" circa 1962. Only with added bad bad jokes. Poor kids. Stuck with terrible writing. (the Americans of course were cowboys.) And then Santa comes and all is well and we have learned something about a couple of cultures along the way. (mainly that in Germany the Christ child brings presents and cowboys in America sing a carol about cowboys at Christmas.)
I've been talking about it with some other friends because I really wondered if I was waaaaaaaaaaaay off base or what. I figured that if Mr. Jenner (who is probably the least reactionary person I know, and who can view many things through a fairly objective perspective) sees this as being awful, it is awful. I mean would they put this play on in other parts of England? I kept thinking, "would this play in London?"
I think that after the play is over I want to have a tiny chat with the headmistress. I want to ask where that particular play came from and say how much I liked the other two and how the kids obviously worked very hard but maybe... it is good to consider (especially in this day and age) the nuances of the material chosen. And if she ever wants the kids to actually learn a bit more about certain cultures why not have more people come in to educate the kids. and I am happy to volunteer with some of these things. I want to think about this a bit because I want her to be open to listen to another perspective "OMG this is freaking uncool." and offer solutions in a polite way. "Hey these aren't far off funny stereotypes. These are real people with complex cultures and experiences and this doesn't help the kids much. Especially if you want them go be well educated and thoughtful members of society." (probably wouldn't help if I yelled, "These are my friends and family dammit. This isn't funny. Do you ever read a fucking book?")
Anyhow...
My children are talented and good looking but I knew that.